PEX System Rundown: Uponor (ProPEX) vs Viega (PureFlow)

Cross-Linked Polyethylene Tubing or PEX plumbing systems have become the norm in new building today with companies continue to find new and innovative uses for the resource. In addition to replacing copper tubing for many traditional plumbing needs it is also an idea choice for radiant floor heating and now quickly becoming a popular option for fire sprinkler installations. Unfortunately all PEX systems are not uniformly configured and there are several systems to consider, hopefully this will give a little background on the different options out there.   

As history will tell us it is common for there to be many players in new technologies but eventually 1 or 2 main players with emerge and they become the standard. Early adopters of Betamax, MiniDiscs & HDDVD will tell you after shelling out small fortunes for the newest gear it can be painful to see you technology never take off. Even though Betamax was a high quality than VHS, it matters little when the technology is gone, majority rules.

PEX plumbing systems are kind of similar, while the tubing itself is standard (PEX-a, PEX-b or PEX-c) there are several proprietary options for the fittings. One thing you don’t want to happen if you are a professional installer is to have your system go away and all the work you have done over many years be with the “Betamax” of PEX Systems.

The two most popular systems on the market today are the Uponor (ProPEX, Wirsbo & AquaPEX) and Viega (PureFlow, ViegaPEX & ProPress) nothing against any other brands but we wanted to focus on these two and look at some of the differences between them. Since we are a tool blog we will also spend some time looking at the fitting tools and how each of those work.

The Uponor system uses the PEX-a tubing which is the most freeze resistant & most flexible PEX tubing available. The fitting system works by expanding the tube then inserting the fitting and utilizing the inherent shape memory of PEX to seal the fitting. A representative for Uponor add “Expanding the tubing allows the use of a larger-diameter fitting, which minimizes restrictions and allows higher flow rates. For 1" tubing connections, Uponor’s ProPEX fitting has 12% greater internal diameter (i.d.) and 25% greater gallons-per-minute (gpm) flow rate than an insert fitting. This is particularly important with the increasing use of PEX in residential fire sprinkler systems, where lower-flow fittings may require larger tubing sizes and additional sprinkler heads.”  

There are several options for fitting tools including manual tools as well as Milwaukee M12 & M18 Expanding Pex Tools. The manual tools ($150+ heads) are going to be very labor intensive to use with the larger fittings or continuously all day long; better suited for the handyman with occasional repair work. The Milwaukee M12 ($399, Ohio Power Tool) and Milwaukee M18 ($699, Ohio Power Tool) are going to be ideal for installation usage with the M12 for smaller diameter PEX and M18 that can handle the entire range of sizes. The Uponor fitting rings are inexpensive as they appear to simply be a small piece of the next size up PEX tubing (although not confirmed) if that is the case and you were in a pinch you could just cut some more yourself.

The Viega PEX system uses the PEX-b tubing (although you could also use another brands PEX-a) and a pressed ring securing the PEX to the fittings. Some advantages with the pressing system is that the fitting are now available with press rings already built-in. For installation the PEX is simply inserted into the fitting and pressed which savers time and makes it so you’ll never run out of the press rings. The downside for the pressing systems is that the fitting have a slightly smaller internal diamete (i.d.) therefore less water can get through vs an expanded fitting system on the same size PEX tube.

With the Viega PEX system you can use manual press tools ($215-380 per size) or automatic Ridgid ProPress Tools. One very large advantage for the Ridgid ProPress (210-B with PEX Jaws) is that you can not only use it with the PEX system but with a simple change of head you can use it for pressing copper and stainless steel pipe & fittings. For situations where you are working with existing plumbing or have work that requires copper you could see these tools being a big advantage. The Ridgid ProPress even has a soil pipe cutter attachment (works with 330-B model), so it is a very versatile system.

For more information directly from the company representatives of Uponor, Viega and Watts checkout this article that was in the Reeves Journal talking about PEX systems and the future of the business.               

    

Comments

comments

This entry was posted in HVAC Tools, Milwaukee, Plumbing Tools, Ridgid and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Comments

  1. Nate says:

    Uponor is far superior to Viega when you are talking about pex systems. Pex-A is a lot better then pex-B and will last longer (especially in a cold climate). You will also have better flow rates and more volume. The Uponor rings ARE NOT just pieces of the next size up, DO NOT attempt to cut your own.

    • nicola says:

      This is just propaganda. There is no difference between Pex-A or Pex-B. All PEX manufacturers need to comply to the ASTM F876 and F877 methodologies in order to meet the minimum
      requirements in USA and Canada or any other locations where PEX pipes must meet those quality standards.
      I’d like to demystify false representations that have circulated over the years by companies trying to convince
      customers that their PEX pipes are better than anyone else. If there is one postulate that you should remember it’s this one: “All certified ASMT F876/ F877 PEX pipes are made equally. Period.”

  2. There are also different types of PEX tubings. It is only right that you give proper respect to each and at least try one out before sticking to your preference.

  3. We use both in our local Minneapolis design/build work and in our national design work. They are not manufactured the same nor are they the same pipe.

    The Uponor has full-flow fittings and can be repaired (heated to straighten out kinked tube) and the Viega PEX cannot.

    Sometimes these things matter, sometimes not.

    We are installing an Uponor combination system for fire protection and potable water. Viega also markets such a system but the Uponor worked best in our local market and on this particular market. It was also more expensive, but it is not all about the initial investment.

    What is important to remember is that both PEX tubing companies are reputable and the ASTM standard exceeds all of the appropriate applications we need for residential and light commercial work, including potable water and snow melting.

    In short, they are better than they need to be and only a skilled and experienced designer can distinguish their respective traits or try for that matter.

    PS… I used both products in my own home and shop.

  4. John Steunenberg says:

    I used PexB on some of my Propex fittings during the plumbing of a reno. That is using the expansion rings. The B grade shows stretch marks once fittings were installed. The PexA had no such issue. Should I be replacing the PexB piping??

  5. Jim Albertson says:

    I have used the manual crimp ring type of system on my plumbing , and it works ok…. some seepage around the fittings that bothered me . This happened even though I used the gauge ! Not much , but still a little that shouldn’t be .
    I am considering the expansion system , though no one seems to be clear about the fittings , and diameter differences ! You can use the regular pex tubing but after you swell the stuff out and slide the fitting in , it will not shrink down for a tight fit .
    I am a tool and die maker , retired, and I have a little knowledge about such things . Either the fittings are larger for the expansion system , or the tubing has a smaller diameter…. Which is it ?

  6. Arun Padhi says:

    Date: 10-11-16

    To, Director / Vice President,

    Sub: Marketing consultant for your plumbing products at India Market

    Dear Sir,

    I am Arun Kumar Padhi, Post-Graduate In Management and having 21+ years experience in Marketing of Building Material specifically 16+ years in pipes related products; worked with corporate like M/s Astral Polytechnik Ltd, Spectrum Paints Pvt.Ltd, M/s Rikvin Floors Ltd.

    We had worked for kitec Industries India Ltd as a marketing consultant at Mumbai and proven a track of 45% cumulative growth in sales including collection and market services.

    Presently we are the Marketing consultants for Kisan Multi Layer Composite Pipes and Fittings in PAN India Basis from 2015 with Kisan Mouldings Ltd, Mumbai.

    I do have a network of approx 200 of stokists and dealers for our ranges of products and having good repo with the builders consultants, Architects, contractors in Major Cities Of India.

    We are a team of professionals who take up the consultancy for establishing the product in the building industry segment on Pan India basis.

    Our range of expertise includes.

    1) Carrying out the Marketing of the product to Consultants, Builders & Contractors.
    2) Making Product presentations on behalf of the company to the Consultants, Builders & Contractors.
    3) Branding & promotion of the product in the market by suitable promotional campaign.
    4) Taking up turnkey contracts on Design & Build basis for the products offered to the customer.
    5) with all above we will be responsible of marketing to sales and to collection having with maintaining the relationship for future business .

    Of doing this I have my independent set up at 61, Cine Max, Beverely Park ,mira Road-401107. Having this kind of set up , I am looking forward to add a new set up from the related industry as a marketing consultant for your range of Products.

    Looking at your set up ; if found suitable , I will take care of recruiting / appointing of Field staff, training, motivation, control/ reporting, appointment of stokists , dealers , Promotion as well as brand Development , sales and collection on marketing consultancy basis which I am doing presently with M/s Kisan Moulding Ltd and having marketing Professionals of 10 nos under my set up.

    We can define the target for your range of product and can expect a minimum 40% growth on yearly basis to your existing business .

    I hope the above will suit for the mutual interest. For further clarification you may please feel free to get in touch with the undersigned at any hour of the day.

    Regards
    Arun Kumar Padhi( MBA)
    41-42, Cine Max, Beverely Park,
    Mira Road-401107
    Mumbai , India

    Mob: 091 9324 26 8898
    Tel: 022-60602090
    Email: Kisancps@gmil.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *